Science Progress | Where science, technology, and progressive policy meet

Announcement Raises Hopes About Cheaper-Than-Coal Solar Technology

SpinCell SOURCE: Courtesy V3Solar A new solar technology reports encouraging results on cost after technical review.

David Roberts at Grist has reported on some interesting news which, if true, would be pretty significant: a new solar technology company claims to have designed a new solar photovoltaic product capable of producing electrons as cheaply as can coal.

Before you read on, its important to note that there are many factors that help determine the final cost of electricity to the consumer (called the “levelized cost of electricity,” or LCOE), and that many of them are difficult to predict and  vary widely from region to region. A global investment bank called Lazard for years has stewarded a methodology for estimating the LCOE for different energy sources based on a number of factors that include the cost of manufacture of the components and equipment, fuel costs, cost of capital, government incentives, land and water requirements, and electricity dispatch characteristics (i.e. the dynamics of integrating the technology into the dynamic bid process of marketing electrons to distributors on the grid).

But given the uncertainty inherent in predicting each of these for new technologies, these estimates must be taken with a grain of salt. It is very difficult to know the true LCOE for a technology that has not yet been widely deployed. Further, the LCOE estimates released by the company, V3Solar were not calculated by Lazard, though they were confirmed by an external technical review.

The long and the short of it is that this announcement is another reason for hope that cheap-as-dirt solar may around the corner, but we’ll still have to wait and see. The rest of Robert’s post is pasted below, or you can read it over at Grist:

Over time I’ve grown more and more suspicious of stories about breakthrough technologies. I always think back to those heady days of EEStor, the guys who were going to make a battery that would revolutionize grid storage and electric cars alike. “EEStor CEO says game-changing energy storage device coming by 2010”! As you may have noticed, 2010 came and went and the game remains unchanged.

All of which is to say, regarding the post to follow: caveat lector.

Still, this looks very, very cool.

CleanTechnica has an exclusive on a new solar technology that claims to be able to produce power with a levelized cost of energy, or  LCOE, of 8¢ per kilowatt-hour. That is mind-boggling, “two-thirds the price of retail electricity and over 3 times cheaper than current solar technology.” If the claim proves to be true (and a lot can happen between prototype and mass manufacturing), it could revolutionize the solar industry.

The company is called V3Solar (formerly Solarphasec) and its product, the Spin Cell, ingeniously solves two big problems facing solar photovoltaics (PV).

First, most solar panels are flat, which means they miss most of the sunlight most of the time. They only briefly face direct sunlight, unless expensive tracking systems are added. The Spin Cell is a cone:


V3Solar Spin Cell


The conical shape catches the sun over the course of its entire arc through the sky, along every axis. It’s built-in tracking.

The second problem: Solar panels produce much more energy if sunlight is concentrated by a lens before it hits the solar cell; however, concentrating the light also creates immense amounts of heat, which means that concentrating solar panels (CPV) require expensive, specialized, heat-resistant solar cell materials.

V3Solar spin cellThe Spin Cell concentrates sunlight on plain old (cheap) silicon PV, but keeps it cool by spinning it.

It’s just so damn clever.

Here’s a video that explains:

The company’s technology claims have been confirmed by a technical review commissioned from independent consultant Bill Rever. As to the 8¢/kWh cost claim, the company told CleanTechnica, “We think we can go below that, but we want to stay conservative.” Hitting it, or close to it, could shake up the energy world. Here’s a chart comparing LCOE for various power sources:

V3Solar: LCOE

That is a whole new ballgame right there.

The company’s aim is to capture 3 percent of the energy market. For context, CleanTechnica notes that “all solar power installed in the U.S. to date currently accounts for about 0.5-1% of the energy market.” More than tripling the size of the U.S. solar market is … well, not short on ambition.

Most impressively, to me, the company tells CleanTechnica that it already has over 4 GW of requests for orders. There is 7 GW of installed solar in the U.S., total.

There’s lots, lots more on the technology over on CleanTechnica, if you want to dig in.

To me, the most exciting implications of the technology (again, if it proves out) are for distributed energy. Spin Cells are only a meter across and quite aesthetically appealing. You could carpet a city in these. Like this:

V3Solar power poles

Maybe this tech or this company will peter out before reaching mass-market scale. But advances in solar technology are coming faster and faster. (Small, distributed energy technologies are inherently more prone to innovation than large, capital-intensive energy technologies.) Sooner or later, solar will be woven seamlessly into the fabric of our lives. Our built environment will harvest energy as a matter of course (from the sun, from the wind, from waste), store it effectively, and use it wisely. Power harvesting and power management will be ubiquitous; power imported from large, distant, polluting power plants over long-distance transmission lines will come to be seen as back-up, a necessary evil. And perhaps, someday, an unnecessary one.

Comments on this article

By clicking and submitting a comment I acknowledge the Science Progress Privacy Policy and agree to the Science Progress Terms of Use. I understand that my comments are also being governed by Facebook's Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.